deli apple-cinnamon cheddar blended with apples and cinnamon makes for a perfect apple pie topper cheddar & spice apple cheddar handcrafted white cheddar and bits of diced apples come together for a sweet savory experience henning's pumpkin- spice or apple cheddar cheeses select varieties pumpkin- spice cheddar creamy wisconsin- made cheddar is mixed with a blend of pumpkin spices