peanut butter star cookies ingredients directions granulated sugar packed brown sugar creamy peanut butter egg all-purpose flour baking soda in flour and baking soda shape dough into 1-inch balls; roll in granulated inches apart on cookie or until edges are light wire rack extra granulated sugar for rolling fleet farm essential everyday essential essential everyday everyday all-purpose flour pure skippy conchas eaches ned granulated sugar creamy pure light brown sugar pana essential everyday essential everyday essential everyday essential everyday grade fleet farm chocolate stars sweet cream hershey's cocoa butter fresh eggs salted lett 15 100% cacao natural unseened sticks netni euro fleet farm 16-oz chocolate stars unsweetened cocoa essential everyday 16-oz sweet cream butter quarters available at select stores essential everyday available at select stores